Are You Ready to Compare Health Insurance Plans?

We have licensed agents ready to take your call.

Call Us NowRequest a Free Quote

By Heather Sprague, Licensed Health Insurance Agent · Reviewed by Michael Sprague, Licensed Health Insurance Agent

Health insurance for 60 year olds costs more, because ACA plans can charge older adults up to 3 times more. Tax credits now stop at 400% of the poverty level, or $63,840 for one person.

That makes your income estimate the biggest money decision before Medicare. Below are five coverage options and the income moves that may keep your savings. Questions? Call 888-730-6031.

Key Takeaways
  • Premiums can be up to three times higher for older adults than for younger ones.
  • Tax credits end above 400% of the poverty level: $63,840 for one, $86,560 for two.
  • Most IRA and 401(k) withdrawals count as income, but qualified Roth withdrawals don't.
  • Pre-tax retirement and HSA contributions can lower the income the marketplace counts.
  • Marketplace coverage doesn't end on its own when Medicare starts, so cancel it yourself.

Why Does Health Insurance for 60 Year Olds Cost More?

Age is one of the few things insurers can use to set ACA premiums. Under federal rules, they can charge older adults up to three times what younger adults pay.

Your health, medical history and sex can't change your price. However, age, location, tobacco use and plan level can, according to HealthCare.gov's guide to premiums. Florida, Texas and Georgia all use the federal default age curve, as listed by CMS market rating rules.

Still, there is good news inside that rule. Tax credits are based on income, not age.

So when your full price is higher, your credit is usually higher too. Our guide to marketplace subsidies explains the full formula.

How Does the Subsidy Cliff Hit People in Their 60s?

The cliff hurts most at this age because full-price premiums are highest. Earn one dollar over 400% of the poverty level, and the whole tax credit disappears.

The extra pandemic-era credits expired, so that hard cutoff is back. Below the line, you pay a set share of income for the benchmark silver plan. Above it, you pay the full price.

Household size400% of poverty levelMost you pay for benchmark silver (300%–400%)
1 person$63,84010.22% of income
2 people$86,56010.22% of income
Over 400%No federal limitFull price, no tax credit

Source: healthinsurance.org subsidy guide, using the poverty guidelines for the coming plan year.

A Simple Example

Say a single 60-year-old expects $63,000 of income. At 10.22%, they would pay about $537 a month for the benchmark silver plan.

Now suppose that plan's full price is $1,100 a month. That figure is an illustration, not a quote.

If income rises to $64,500, the credit vanishes, and the cost jumps by about $6,700 a year. For more detail, read our ACA subsidy cliff guide.

Close to the Cliff?

A licensed Vivna agent can check how your income estimate changes your price at no cost. Call 888-730-6031 or request a free quote.

What Income Counts for Health Insurance at 60?

When you shop for health insurance for 60 year olds, the marketplace counts most retirement income, including Social Security. Only a few sources are left out, so list every one before you apply.

Counts as incomeDoesn't count
Taxable and nontaxable Social SecurityQualified Roth distributions
Most IRA and 401(k) withdrawalsGifts and loan proceeds
Pension incomeSupplemental Security Income (SSI)
Capital gains, interest and dividends, including tax-exempt interestVeterans' disability payments
Wages and self-employment incomeChild support

Source: HealthCare.gov: What to include as income.

Ways to Time Your Retirement Income

Because the cliff is a hard line, timing matters. These moves may help you stay under it if you qualify.

  • Draw from a Roth account: qualified Roth withdrawals don't count as income.
  • Fund pre-tax accounts: pre-tax retirement and HSA contributions lower the income used for subsidies.
  • Spread out large withdrawals: a big IRA draw or home-sale gain can push one year over the line.
  • Update your application: report income changes during the year so your credit stays accurate.

These choices affect your taxes too, so talk to a tax professional about your situation. If you are self-employed, our guide to self-employed health deductions covers another way to lower taxable income.

What Are Your Health Insurance Options at 60?

Most shoppers comparing health insurance for 60 year olds choose among five paths. The right one depends on your income, your health and how long you need coverage.

OptionWho it may fitWatch out for
1. Marketplace plan with a tax creditIncome between 100% and 400% of the poverty levelIncome estimates that run high or low
2. Full-price ACA planIncome over the cliff, or ongoing health needsHigh premiums, so compare metal levels
3. COBRARecent retirees in the middle of treatmentCoverage time limits and full cost
4. A spouse's job-based planCouples where one spouse still worksWhether the plan covers spouses, and at what cost
5. Short-term planHealthy people in approved statesNot ACA coverage; health questions apply

First, check the marketplace, since ACA plans must accept you regardless of health. Also, compare plan levels with our bronze, silver and gold plan guide. If you just left a job, our COBRA vs. marketplace comparison can help.

Over the cliff? See our list of coverage choices without subsidies.

In approved states, Vivna also offers UnitedHealthcare short-term plans. They are not ACA coverage, may exclude pre-existing conditions and require health questions.

How Should People in Their 60s Plan for Medicare?

Mark your 65th birthday early, since Medicare timing affects your marketplace plan. Your first sign-up window runs from three months before to three months after that birthday.

Tax credits stop once you qualify for premium-free Part A. Also, marketplace coverage doesn't end on its own when Medicare starts. You must update your application, according to HealthCare.gov's Medicare transition page.

Waiting too long can bring Medicare late penalties that grow over time. Ask Medicare or a Medicare specialist about plan choices. Meanwhile, keep any younger spouse covered, because they may still need a marketplace plan.

Retiring Before 65

Leaving work at 60 or 62 means several years of coverage before Medicare. Our guide to early retirement coverage walks through a budget for that gap.

Health Insurance for 60 Year Olds FAQs

Can an insurer turn me down because of my health at 60?

Not for an ACA plan. Marketplace and other ACA plans can't deny you or charge more for a pre-existing condition. However, short-term plans can, because they ask health questions.

So, if you take regular medications or see specialists, start with an ACA plan. You can buy one during Open Enrollment or after a qualifying life event.

Do my Social Security benefits count if I claim early at 62?

Yes. HealthCare.gov counts both taxable and nontaxable Social Security. As a result, claiming early adds income that may move you closer to the cliff.

Before you file a claim, run the numbers with your tax professional. Then update your marketplace application with the new monthly amount.

Is a bronze plan a good idea for pre-Medicare health insurance?

It can be, if you are healthy and want the lowest premium. Bronze plans have high deductibles, though, so one hospital stay can cost thousands.

Also, bronze plans are now HSA-eligible, which may help you save pre-tax money. Our health insurance FAQ library answers more questions about plan levels.

Next Steps for Health Insurance for 60 Year Olds

Health insurance for 60 year olds is mostly an income question. First, list every income source for the coming year. Next, see where it falls against the cliff, and then compare plans before December 15.

Ready for help? Call a licensed Vivna agent at 888-730-6031, Monday through Friday, 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Eastern. You can also browse our individual and family health plans, or read about income-based coverage.

Sources

  1. HealthCare.gov: How insurance companies set health premiums
  2. CMS: Market rating reforms
  3. healthinsurance.org: Will you receive an ACA premium subsidy?
  4. HealthCare.gov: What to include as income
  5. HealthCare.gov: Changing from the Marketplace to Medicare

Related Guides

Heather Sprague, licensed health insurance agent at Vivna Insurance

About the author: Heather Sprague

Heather is the owner and agent of record at Vivna Insurance, a licensed independent agency in Deerfield Beach, Florida. She helps families and self-employed workers compare marketplace, short-term and supplemental plans. Licensed health insurance agent, Vivna Insurance (Agency NPN 19168641). Call 888-730-6031.

Reviewed by Michael Sprague, licensed health insurance agent.

Vivna Insurance is a licensed independent agency, not a government website. Our help is free; we are paid by the insurance companies we work with. This post is general information, not tax or Medicare advice. Talk to a tax professional about your situation. Savings depend on income and eligibility.

Find Local Health Insurance Help

Plans, prices and help programs change by state and even by county. These local guides show what is available near you.

More local help: the Florida health insurance guide, plus guides for Texas, Georgia, North Carolina and every state we serve.

Prefer to talk it through? Call 888-730-6031 Monday through Friday, 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Eastern, for free help from a licensed agent.